Employee Accountability: Discipline or Safety Net

Feb 7, 2019, Written by Sue Miley

Employee Accountability

As small business owners who want to build our businesses on Christian values we are constantly challenged to find the intersection between wise business decisions and sound Biblical Principles. In many areas, we might initially see contradictions between the two.  As a Christian Small Business Coach, many of my clients have expressed frustration and confusion when trying to apply their principles to real life events.

One of the intersections that seems to perplex Christian business owners the most is how and when to hold employees accountable for their performance, while still being compassionate, loving, forgiving and charitable.

When I met Jeff, he was about to throw in the towel on his business.  He was a good attorney, but he just couldn’t get his team right.  He would hire an employee and it seems like from day 1 the employee would have a million excuses about why they couldn’t come to work on time or had to take a day off.  Everyone had issues.  They had sick children, legal issues in their divorce, or were down and out and having to share someone else’s car.  Each excuse, by itself, seemed reasonable.  These employees had genuine hardship.  Jeff felt compassion for his brothers and sisters.  He couldn’t just fire them because after all they really needed a job and he did not want to ignore his desire to be charitable and help those in need.  He felt like he was trying to do the right thing as a Christian, but as a business owner it just made him feel trapped – and it was hurting his business.

Another client, Ed had an administrative assistant who just wasn’t pulling her weight.  She had started out strong but now was cutting corners and making mistakes.  He had mentioned the problems to her, but things weren’t changing.  Ed only had 5 employees including himself.  If even one person did not pull their own weight it had a huge impact on the business and all the other employees. 

When I asked him if he wanted to replace her he actually looked surprised.  I guess because I am a Christian coach, I am not supposed to suggest replacing an employee? And even considering firing her made him feel bad.  He thought that maybe as a Christian he hadn’t really done everything he could to help her be successful. At the same time, he felt confused and frustrated about how to hold her accountable to the standards of work she had agreed to do – and had done well in the past.

I understand this difficult dilemma first hand.  As a convert to Christianity, I went through a period just after becoming a Christian where I wasn’t sure how to act in my business at all anymore.  I wanted to reinterpret my motivation, goals, and actions from a biblical perspective.  I felt I could no longer make decisions based on what actually worked in business, but only based on what Jesus would do.  And that is where the real challenge and solution lies – in developing a true understanding of what Jesus, the business owner, would do – an understanding of what Jesus would have you do as a business owner.

What Would Jesus, the Business Owner, Do?

Jesus was fair and compassionate. He taught love and forgiveness.  He commanded us to serve and help those in need. But, he did not ignore people who ignored their commitment to God’s commandments.  He did not offer blanket forgiveness for all behavior, as long as the person could claim ‘hardship.’  He did not lower his standards to make righteousness easier for those facing challenges in life. He held people accountable to God’s word.  

Jesus was a leader, he took action, and he held people accountable.  He was decidedly and firmly against hypocrisy, selfishness, and greed.  He was tough on people with bad intentions.  He taught us about the possible rewards of doing the right thing, but also about the consequences of doing wrong. 

Somehow many Christians have come to believe that love, compassion and charity translate into never holding people accountable.  Accountability is too often equated with being ‘mean’ or ‘unfair.’ We have become wishy-washy in our expectations and unpredictable in our decisions.  This is not what Jesus would do. As a Christian we can absolutely hold ourselves, and others, accountable. As a matter of fact, it is actually the charitable thing to do.

Tough Love

What kind of success will a person have in life if she is never expected to rise to the occasion, keep her word, or be responsible for her choices?  Without accountability, we would become spoiled, helpless children – too weak for this world.  When you hold employees accountable, you are offering them an opportunity to embrace the behaviors that will bring them success and satisfaction in any area of life in the future.  You are helping them to be the best possible version of themselves. And, you are helping them live up to the values that God commands.

If we believe our Christian values are what God expects of us – if we believe they are important enough to consider when we screen potential employees in the hiring process – if we believe they are so important to our success that we commit them to paper in our policies and procedures, then why would we fail to hold ourselves and our employees to those standards when the ‘rubber hits the road?’

Of course, good management precedes accountability and is still necessary even if God is at the center of every employees’ heart. 

If it is important you need to follow up.  Measurements need to be in place.  Conversations and open dialogue reviewing how a project went.  And discussions about our work quality is also okay.   Did we execute to the best of our abilities this week?

If you build accountability into your culture it is seen as a positive support system, not a punitive disciplinary process. 

It is the same reason that as a Christian we are thankful we have the Bible to understand and know our boundaries.  It is our support system and safety net.  Accountability may include discipline, but it is much more a positive safety net to ensure we live up to our commitments.  As a business owner, it is positive to hold ourselves and our team accountable.

I still believe it is what Jesus would do.

Reader Interactions


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Sue Miley

Sue Miley MBA, MA, LPC helps small business owners build successful businesses on a foundation of Christian values. After 20 years in business, and 10 years as a Christian counselor, Sue uses a combination of faith, business and psychology to help clients in business and in life.

Related Posts

recruiting employees for small businesses

Grow Your Own: How Small Businesses Can Recruit and Develop Success

By Jim Miley | May 9, 2023

It’s unanimous; we’re in an employee’s job market with no end in sight for employers struggling to recruit and retain good people. I read articles, […]

Read More
easy to do business with

Are You Easy To Do Business With?

By Jim Miley | March 31, 2023

Small business owners face so many challenges that it’s easy to lose sight of one of the most fundamental competitive advantages, “being easy to business […]

Read More
effective office skills for administrative support staff

Administrative Support for Staff

By Michelle Bankston | March 14, 2023

A business has a lot of working parts to keep the business running. Administrative Assistants play a key role in supporting the team. So, how […]

Read More